Multiple sender rule

A multiple sender rule detects one account receiving money from an unusually large number of distinct senders inside a time window. It is the mirror of the multiple beneficiary rule and looks for the collection step of a scheme, where payments from many victims are gathered into a single account.

The fraud scenario this rule addresses

In a scam or a collection scheme, many victims each pay a small amount to the same account. No single payment looks odd, but the account receives from far more unrelated senders than an ordinary personal account would. Fake online shops, investment scams and romance fraud with a shared collection account all produce this shape.

A mule account also collects from several sources before consolidating the funds and moving them on.

Data the rule requires

Example logic

Illustrative pseudocode: it compares each event with the rule's parameters and flags the ones that match. Parameters are symbolic: every value is institution-specific and has to be derived from your own transaction distribution.

RULE multiple_sender
  FOR EACH incoming payment P to account A:
    window_credits = credits WHERE receiver = A
                               AND timestamp > P.timestamp - :window
    distinct_senders = count_distinct(window_credits.sender)
    new_senders      = count_distinct(window_credits.sender
                                      WHERE no prior relationship)
    IF distinct_senders >= :max_senders
       AND new_senders / distinct_senders >= :new_sender_share:
      RAISE alert(rule = "multiple_sender",
                  account = A, evidence = window_credits)

Choosing a threshold

The sender count, the window, and the share of senders who are new to the account are the levers. Raising the count reduces alerts on ordinary accounts but lets a scheme collect from a modest number of victims unnoticed. A narrow window catches a rapid collection but misses one that trickles in over weeks.

The share of unrelated senders is the parameter that separates a scheme from a popular business. A shop with many customers has many senders, but they are repeat customers over time. An account whose senders are nearly all new in a short period looks quite different.

As with the beneficiary rule, thresholds must be per segment: a business account is expected to receive from many payers, a personal account is not.

False positives to expect

Legitimate accounts that collect from many people are numerous: a sole trader or small shop, a club or society collecting subscriptions, a fundraiser for a funeral or a medical need, a landlord with several tenants, a crowdfunding page, a group organiser collecting contributions for a trip, and a seller on a marketplace.

Separating personal accounts from trading accounts, and recognising a customer who has declared a business purpose, removes most of this. Established accounts that have received from many senders for a long period are lower risk than ones where the pattern is new.

Investigating an alert from this rule

  1. List the senders and see how many are new to the account, and when each first paid.
  2. Look at the amounts: a run of similar amounts suggests a price, as in a scam offer, rather than free-form transfers.
  3. Check the payment references and any stated purpose for consistency.
  4. Check whether any of the senders have been reported as victims or appear in other cases.
  5. Look at what happens to the money after it arrives. Rapid onward movement raises concern considerably.
  6. Establish whether the account holder is trading legitimately, and tag the account if the evidence points to collection of scam proceeds.

Related rules

Where this rule fits

The use case this rule supports is covered in mule accounts, and the fraud rules engine page describes how conditions like these are expressed and versioned.

Common questions

What is a multiple sender rule?

A multiple sender rule is a fraud rule that raises an alert when one account receives money from an unusually large number of different senders inside a time window. It detects the collection step of a scam or mule scheme, where many victims each pay a modest amount into a single account that an ordinary personal account would not attract.

The share of senders who are new to the account is the key discriminator. A busy shop receives from many people, but mostly repeat customers over time, whereas a collection account for a scam receives from many unrelated people in a short period.

Clubs, fundraisers, landlords and traders legitimately collect from many payers, so the rule is normally applied differently to personal and trading accounts.

Discuss your transaction monitoring requirements

Tell us which transaction flows you need to monitor, which systems Akoben would integrate with, and how your fraud team works today.

Request a demo